Greenpoint grocery stores, one woman's opinion:
Associated, Manhattan & Calyer: How does this excuse for a grocery store even stay in business? The help is surly, the selection poor, the odor disgusting. I know the answer: the large selection of imported Polish foods. It closes at 8pm, and I try to avoid going there for anything beyond emergency essentials.
Key Food, McGuinness & Greenpoint Ave.: The crown jewel of grocery stores in the area, but I have a car so I am spoiled. That said, the walk isn't that much further if you are carless, and the selection is superior. However, they have similarly ridiculous hours - which I hear (via the boyfriend) are expanding. But there is no reason this store isn't 24 hours or isn't at least open until 11pm weeknights.
C Town, Manhattan & Java: This store was so inferior when I first moved to Greenpoint that it never entered my consciousness. However, when the boyfriend relocated to the nabe, he was unaware of my existing prejudices and would stop there for items on the way home (since he shares my hatred of the Associated). Someone in the store or the company paid attention to the burgeoning community growing in Greenpoint, or just decided to try to compete with the Garden. The store was renovated, and the selection expanded to include the likes of organic vegetables and Silk soy milk, while still maintaining its extensive Goya selection. It is, however, more expensive than either the Associated or Key Foods. I don't know what time they close, but I suspect they're not exactly pioneering anything past the standard Manhattan Ave. 8pm commercial curfew.
The Garden, Manhattan & Greenpoint Ave.: Either you love the Garden or you hate it. I want to love the Garden, but find the aisles cramped, the selection impossible to comprehend, and the help even surlier than the Associated (which is hard to do). It is convenient when I need or want the occasional organic item, but they are more expensive than even Whole Paycheck. I understand that is the premium for convenience, but the attitude and the tiny aisles remove the convenience factor and make me just want to go down to Union Square. They also close at 8pm, which is just silly - they'd be packed until 9 or 10pm easily.
That said, we have FOUR grocery stores in the zip code, while Bedford-area Williamsburg has to deal with Tops (a store I do not understand and avoid) or the newly renovated C-Town (is it C-Town or Associated?) on Havemeyer. There are a few more grocery stores out towards Graham, but I always perceived them as tiny and typical low-income area-type stores, e.g., limited selection and jacked-up prices (hey, I lived in the Bronx in the 80s, don't start).
Where are all the yuppies moving into the condos going to shop? No, seriously, Karl Fischer Row - where are those people going to get their food? Not everyone orders from Fresh Direct. They don't even have anything within shouting distance.